With all the recent fuss over the boys and young men–their toxicity, their lostness, the ways in which they have been failed, their search for meaning, their search for identity, their love affair with problematic podbros, their obsession with looksmaxxing–I can’t help but go back to the an underrated classic, by a feminist author who prophetically foresaw it all over a generation ago.
Susan Faludi is probably still best known for her debut book, Backlash: The Undeclared War Against American Women, which examined the way advances towards gender-equity were being met with a vitriolic social push in the opposite direction. However, while researching that book, she became fascinated by the question of why the men she interviewed seemed both so angry and so insecure, despite seemingly having all the world’s favor on their side. To her credit, she didn’t just dismiss it as whining by an entitled but fragile gender, but actually dug deeper to find root causes, leading to the publication of her 1999 classic, Stiffed: The Betrayal of the American Man. The book is a tome, nearly the size of a phonebook, but every section is a deeply fascinating dive into a different, endangered masculine subculture. Her deep insights continue to stay with me, and inform the way I see the world and my own identity as a man. Among the deeply current trends she saw coming are:
Toxic Masculinity: I’d say her key insight is that toxic masculinity is NOT masculinity in overdrive. It’s not an excess of masculinity. It’s actually a reaction to a deficiency, a deficiency in positive masculinity. When fathers are absent, distant, disengaged or estranged, individually or as a pervasive social phenomenon, sons have no positive image of masculinity to emulate, and so they build a male identity as a rejection of femininity. Misogyny, sexual abusiveness, crudeness, promiscuity, anger, destructiveness, posturing, peacocking, hyper-competitiveness, aggressive belligerence and irresponsibility are reconfigured as ideals to aspire to rather than vices to be overcome. They are experienced as a brave effort at liberation from the tyranny of the mother and her values, rather than as a nadir of human behavior.
Ironically, when the women in these men’s lives likewise suffer from a lack of positive male role models, they may also contribute to the rise of toxic masculinity by expecting that their sons and their lovers exhibit toxic masculine or “mannish” behaviors, and by deriding them as effeminate when they don’t.
The cure is strong, present, engaged fathers and father figures who can model better ways of behavior, and who are capable of guiding young men through conquering their vices, and who are willing to be firm rather than indulgent in demanding the best from them. One thing Faludi said on this score that has always stuck with me is that although we tend to think of “nurturing” as a feminine trait, it’s actually a core component of positive masculinity as well. The difference, at least according to Faludi, is that women most often nurture a family, whereas men most often nurture a larger community.
Right or wrong, it’s a provocative analysis, and it opens the door to look at other distinctly male versions of what we often see as feminine traits–what it means for a man to be be loving, caring, and emotionally demonstrative, to excel at things like dancing, cooking, fashion, etcetera.
There are a number of important other topics that Faludi tackles in her book, but since this post has gotten long, I’m going to save those for the future. Join me back here, and we’ll look at her insights into looksmaxxing, homoerotic homophobia, and racial typecasting.